Rant alert!
Not long ago I had a day's work in a school on the outskirts of Bradford. A couple of days ago I got an
envelope from Bradford – I figured it was a remittance advice for the work I did. It wasn’t – it was a bloody penalty charge notice. Apparently I had ventured into the Bradford Low Emission Zone. I knew they had one – there are notices on the motorway and I had read about it a while ago so I knew it was there. As the school is in Allerton which is not in the city at all. I decided to go via Harrogate and up round the top so that I avoided the city.
I'm very boring - I try to stick to the speed limit, I avoid bus lanes and I've never even had a parking ticket never mind a speeding ticket. I try to be courteous and observant but I never saw a single bloody sign. Add in that it was a totally unfamiliar area and you are following directions, observing speed limits, bus lanes, junctions, pedestrians and other traffic. Surely if you are entering a charging zone there should be CLEAR signage, not zero of minimal signage.
If I had known, then I would simply have added the charge to the invoice and charged it to the client, the same as I charged them travel expenses. The first time I knew I had entered the charging zone was when the fine arrived.
It looks like I'm not alone, either:
(a) I saw this online when I searched for what the signs might look like <<BE WARNED>>>> have just received a £120 fine (reduced to £60) for non payment of driving in the Bradford area clean air zone. I drive a T5 campervan and had absolutely no idea that Bradford had a clean air zone, or saw any sign advertising the fact. I visited Haworth in my van for the first time on 28/4 and today (15/5) received a fine in the post for non payment of fine. The £9 a day charge is steep enough without having to pay £60 when there was no obvious signage to inform me to pay. First and last trip to the area from Lincolnshire. If you appeal the fine then you risk having to pay £180 if you lose the appeal. I understand now that I had to pay £9 but feel there should be at least some warning, and a one off chance of explaining that I had no idea there was a clean air zone!>>
b) a friend commented: << Me and my brother got caught out by this last year when we drove into Saltaire from Harrogate, neither of us knew about, oblivious we were, neither of us could remember seeing any signs. >>
c) another friend commented: <<I got caught out by that last year too. I just crossed over the long thin bit for a mile or so visiting friends in Bingley and then back across it again the next day. Luckily they only got me going in one direction otherwise I would have had 2 fines. Totally inadequate signage. I had no idea until the fine came through the door >>
d) and someone else: <<The LEZ around Bradford is huge and frankly ridiculous. We use a garage near Keighley for our trucks and one is a Euro 5 spec so costs £50 every time we take it into the LEZ! We have to travel towards Skipton then through Silsden to avoid it. Not the best journey in a 44t HGV.
The whole LEZ and ULEZ system a racketeering at it finest. >>
And then I find out that this doesn't apply to private vehicles, only commercial vehicles. I could drive a diesel vehicle the same age through with no charge. Of course, charging private vehicles would have cost them votes, so it clearly is NOT about emissions but about revenue from a council that can't balance its books (they are one of the councils given the go ahead by Angela Rainer to increase their council tax way above what is normally allowed. My business is still struggling to rebuild after the ravages of Covid and yet councils like this just see businesses as an easy target for revenue generation.
All the same, if there had been clear signage to make it crystal clear that you are entering a chargeable zone I wouldn't have felt so aggrieved. As I say, I'd have been able to add it to the invoice (or I could have just paid the damn thing). The thing that really pisses me off is that it really isn't clear and the first you know about it is when the fine arrives, and then it is difficult to contest. So you set up something that you are going to charge people for, but don't make it clear when it applies and then fine them for not paying because they didn't know. Surely that 's deception. Tell me that isn't a scam!